Out “wowing” WoW

I am going to preface this post with a disclaimer:  Aion will not “kill” WoW.  I don’t think anything will “kill” WoW.  I don’t think anything will be as big as WoW in the MMO world for a very, very long time.  WoW came out at exactly the right time, with exactly the right system requirements and made MMOs accessible for the first time.  It was an aberration in many ways and rode very well thought out gameplay, low system requirements and pop culture endorsements to the top.  Many of its players are not even gamers but got into the game through friends and found themselves addicted to the ease of gameplay and “carrot-on-a-stick” reward system.  Those players will, probably, not go to another game when they quit WoW.  They will quit the MMO world entirely.

That being said Aion, or any other new MMO, does not have to beat WoW to be successful, although that is the common misconception among MMO fans and bloggers such as myself.  I would consider LotRO a success, though it has “only” 250,ooo or so subs, I would consider Eve a definite success even though it has “only” about the same number of subs.  Because WAR is in a fight to stabilize its sub base and AoC has dropped to 100,000 (or less depending on who you talk to), I would say the jury is still out on those titles.

So, how does Aion fit in this crowded MMO battle?  How do they “compete” with WoW?    I know the game already has a couple of advantages over recent competition, it has phenomenal graphics that run very well at even the highest settings in crowded areas and it has a control scheme that feels as “tight” and responsive as WoW.  So, what else can they do to grab WoW players who are starting to get into the post-expansion doldrums?  How do they out-wow WoW?


WoW does not have the best PvP in the genre.  It doesn’t have the best PvE.  What it does have is very good PvP and PvE.  WoW gives you a variety of things to do no matter your playstyle.  Hate PvP but love raids?  WoW has content for you.  Hate raids but love small group content?  WoW has content for you, too.  Like to solo?  Like to group?  Like small scale PvP?  Large scale PvP?  It doesn’t matter what you like, WoW had something for you.

Aion must do the same.  Give players a variety of things to do, not only while leveling but at endgame.  Some players do not like a certain style of MMO gaming, not having something for them means they quit.  Players get tired of doing one thing over and over, doing PvP 24/7 can get boring, so can doing instances 24/7.  Give players options and you will reap the benefits of that variety.

Borrow concepts and improve on them

Blizzard is the master of borrowing ideas and gameplay concepts from competitors and improving upon them.  Questing and instances were nothing new when WoW came out, but quests and instances in WoW were taken and polished to a high shine and seemed totally new because of it.  WAR advertised Keep sieges and massive PvP battles, so WoW introduced Wintergrasp.  LotRO’s claim to fame was story driven quests, so in WotLK, Blizzard introduced story driven quests and “phased” areas that allowed them to tell a story in a completely new way.

NCSoft needs to look at the current MMO world and take what is popular and improve upon it.  Arenas are huge in WoW, take them and improve upon them in some way.  Public Quests are one of WARs claims to fame, take that and improve upon a great concept with flawed execution.  Tabula Rasa’s cloning system was incredibly cool, take that and improve upon it.  There are literally hundreds of things that can be taken and improved upon.  Do it better and faster than Blizzard and you have a winner.

Support Video and Machinima

This may seem out of left field compared to my other points, but I think the huge influx of WoW videos on YouTube and on websites such as Warcraft Movies, played a tremendous part in the growth of WoW.  Players and potential players saw the PvP and raid videos on YouTube and said “I want to do that!”.  The buzz created by the Leeroy Jenkins, Mordots and Big Blue Dress videos was instrumental in its popularity.

Aion needs to do the same, it is already a very photogenic and “video-genic” game.  It looks amazing, so host a video site to show it off!  Hold contests for the best video of the week.  Have the talented video editors of the gaming world making videos about your product and you have thousands of videos that are, essentially, free advertisments of Aion.

Support the Fansites and Blogs

I am not suggesting this to be self-serving, even though this is an Aion blog, I am posting it because it is one of the best ways to increase the popularity of your game.  WAR took huge advantage of this, the amount of blogs and fansites dedicated to WAR pre-release was phenomenal, but even more amazing was how involved Mythic was with those fansites.  They gave interviews to small blogs and fansites, hosted contests through them and, most importantly, connected to their future player base to them.  WoW is the same way in a lot of respects.  Try to look up the strategy for a boss fight in LotRO, you may find one or two sites with information out there, now try to do the same for WoW and you will find hundreds and hundreds of sites out there.

Aion is already behind in this regard.  As of this moment I know very few sites dedicated to Aion.  Aion Source is the biggest, Aion Global is another and then there are the blogs of which I know only two, this one and Persepha Productions.  My apologies in advance if I missed one and if I did please comment and let me know so that I can add it to my links on the blog!  Regardless, there are not many and there should be more, many more.  Aion’s fansite link on their main site shows only two fansites, the aformentioned Aion Source and Aion Global.  This is not acceptable.  NCSoft has to cultivate a fansite and blog community in todays crowded market.  Host some competitions through them, give exclusive interviews and, in turn, the buzz for the game will grow.

Well, that’s my short list for “out-wowing” WoW.  Some of you may be surprised that much of the list is not actually in-game stuff, but I think beating WoW in gameplay is only half the battle.  Build a solid community and it will draw more people in to your game.  WoW has done a tremendous job at this over the years.

As I said, even if Aion nails every one of these they are still not going to be as big as WoW, but they will have a great foundation and they will be well on their way to being the second biggest MMO in the world.

Tomorrow I am going to talk more in preparation of the next phase of beta and what I am going in looking for.  See you then!


7 Responses

  1. The one single thing that has stood out to me during the beta is the lack of an auto-loot feature. It’s very frustrating not to have one. Camera controls being added would also be nice.

    The way I see it, companies would be smart to really use the WoW control template when creating their games. For example, in WoW I can press the ‘b’ key and open my bag, but in Aion this key is mapped by default to the power stone thing. It’s easy to go in and re-map the key to my bags, but intuitively ‘b’ should be for my bags only because WoW has such a large player base and decided ‘b’ should be for bags. Windows is a perfect example of this. People know that left clicking items should bring up a small windowed list of actions to perform. Because Windows is so huge and because so many people are familiar with that, if Microsoft suddenly change the function of the left click it would irritate a lot of people just because that’s accepted.

  2. Aion has already been developed and is released in NKorea and China. Do not expect any customization to the game other than region language support and a possible tweaking of XP to eleminate the grind feel Aion China currently posses.

    • I don’t expect many changes from the current Korean version. The game is close to release to make any. This is what I would suggest going forward, however.

      Also, half of my suggestions were for things that were not in the game but things that NCSoft West could do through their website and through community relations.

  3. Besides nitpicking the interface which is what most WoW fanboys will do, lets talk about the revolutionary PVP and the neat lore and world Aion the game is set in compared to WoW’s now diluted lore (pay to switch sides, dwarf beecomes a blood elf..nice)and over simplification.

    • But, but….nitpicking is so fun! Its so horrible that I have to hit ‘I’ for my inventory instead of ‘B’ for my bags. Thats just not right.

      Seriously, though, I agree that the interface should be somewhat similar for familiarities sake. But, nitpicking the small things is ludicrous. Interface wise the only thing I really wish they would add is the ability to turn off target lock. I am so used to being able to click on the ground to clear my target it kills me that its not there. I am probably alone in this though, heh.

  4. I was surprised to read that there were only two sites listed in the fan listing but then realized you were looking at the US page. The EU site has tons more fansite links:


  5. As both a “WoW-fanboy” and someone really enjoying early beta time with Aion, I must admit that I found the buttons initially annoying as well… however, I *like* the feeling that I’m playing a “new” game and have to retrain my fingers. It would be a shame if Aion cows too much to WoW just because of popularity. I think they’ve had the perfect balance so far of being “WoW-like” without being “WoW-copy”.

    I can get on board with wanting an auto-loot though :-D.

    If the word of mouth continues, we’ll get some good blogs going too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: